Quote: (06-02-2015 07:49 PM)trian1 Wrote:
I think what many here are overlooking is that this brings gender and neuroscience into the foreground of public discussion.
Most people here believe that there are distinct biological differences between the brains of males and those of females -- we have developed to be different and complimentary. Several recent studies support this:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neuroscienc...ifferences
So if one can have a predominantly male brain, or female brain, it is easier to understand how one could suffer from being born with a female brain in a male body. One such study supports that: http://www.newscientist.com/article/dn20...-scan.html
This is what makes it different from body integrity identity disorder, or someone who thinks they are Napoleon, when they are not -- one can have a female biological brain structure, and it might not match the biology of the body.
Now neuroscience is difficult, and constantly changing, several studies show the opposite of the links above.
However, if science continues to confirm that the sexes have different brain structures/pathways, and that transgenders have a brain biology consistent with the sex that doesn't match the rest of their body, then it forces us to have to take seriously that, well, gender is not just a social construct, but rooted in biology. Men and women are different.
Now, the current treatment of gender dysphoria, to make the body appear to match the brain, is debatable. I suspect that will continue to be questioned, particularly since the long-term prognosis is dim for many of those getting a full, irreversible procedure.
It is upsetting that the masses see this as a social justice issue, rather than a medical issue. I would hope that this press wouldn't make someone suffering with such issues to decide to just "be who you are meant to be" rather than to seek the help of a trained medical doctor. But that is not the vibe I am getting from the media coverage.
I think the societies that have recognized "third genders" for transgenders, rather than trying to rewrite history and pretend there is not a disconnect between the person's brain and body, probably are on to something.
Would it be easier to try to realign neural pathways and shape the brain to match the body instead of slicing and dicing the body to match the brain? I doubt any research will be done on that front, as it would be considered transphobic.
How often does the body get the brain / body genders incorrect? If someone's DNA produces a male body, how often would that same DNA produce a female brain IN that body? Along the same rates as true hermaphrodites? More? Less? Seems like it would be fairly rare, but who knows.
It is well known that brains can change over time based on what information we repeatedly feed them. Neural pathways can get wired into them that are very difficult to break, though not impossible. Does obsessing about being a woman alter one's brain chemistry to the point where that person's brain looks different than a typical "normal" heterosexual non-trans brain?
Without studying the brains of everyone who claims to be transgendered, what is to stop people who aren't truly transgendered (with mismatching brain/bodies) from simply making attention whoring claims of being transgendered?
There is still no known "gay gene", but being homosexual is so socially acceptable now, anyone with the slightest inclination has no qualms about giving it a try.
What about hormones and antibiotics, etc. that were unknown in our food supply 100+ years ago? There are studies starting to be done into our microbiome that show if you are born vaginally or via cesarean section, it makes a difference to your bodies development and could make a person more susceptible to certain illnesses later in life (Crohn's disease, and other gut problems). There are so many possible variables to what might be the root cause of this stuff, but I don't think anyone is trying to find it.
I'm all over the map in this post, but this is such a slippery slope and society is sliding down it full steam ahead. And with the political correctness police and SJW's out in full force on these issues, I don't think the proper studies will ever be done to figure out what is causing these types of problems. In fact, I probably am not allowed to call them problems. Why study what is making people gay and transgendered in increasing rates? Since there is absolutely nothing wrong with being gay or transgendered, we don't need to figure out what is happening or why, because it is beautiful and everyone is great and wonderful and isn't this diversity terrific? Let's throw a big parade.