He lost me at "go back to Africa" but I can see why he might say that. He may have visited Tanzania, but I'd like to see him do at least a year abroad in Tanzania before he dismissively tells anyone they should move to a location. I've been abroad for nearly 2 years and I still hesitate before telling anyone "move to china! all your problems will be solved!" There is a ton of bullshit you deal with living in Asia that you don't have back home but also a ton of pluses that make me really like it. It's a balance.
Doesn't matter if we are also black. There would be tons of challenges we'd face moving to an African nation. We would be outsiders there and I doubt many of us are used to a place of that nature where it's blazing hot, reasonably poor medical standards, questionable construction standards, poor infrastructure (in comparison to America) and a slew of other problems. Is that really something we can genuinely tell our brothers to go into? I couldn't.
There are a lot of blacks who complain about USA and rightfully so, but those same blacks also recognize that America is probably still in the top 5 best places to live as a black man. There is a ton of bullshit but also a lot you can do there. I left because I wanted to leave but I don't fault any black man for staying and taking advantage of all that stuff.
I did take issue with him criticizing the black people who complain. The American way is to complain and point out the bad things. That's just how we are. It isn't just blacks. It's a deep part of the American character. We let others know what we don't like.
The thing with that though is that we are so deeply alienated from Africa at this point that it isn't like going back home. We have almost no connection to that place other than DNA.
We aren't going to just show up and suddenly go "ahh, my people" in fucking Bantu languages while dancing to perfectly synchronized drum beats that unlock our latent African ancestral memories.
The thing that I don't think a lot of people realize is that many black Americans are just too deeply American to go back. I love being American. There is no other passport I want. Fuck dual citizenship.
Same with most white americans and Europe. I don't have too many white friends back home who keep in touch with their distant European cousins (if they even have any). I think this idea of returning back to the homeland is a hokey and overly sentimental.
That's a lot like trying to crawl back into the womb. Doesn't work that way. You can return to the location but the state is vastly altered. For all I know the tribe or kingdom I may have descended from is now all the way up north Africa. Who the fuck knows?
We cannot undo the past, we can simply move forward. If a few more African nations stabilize I would consider visiting, but I would be going in the capacity of a visitor, not as some dude trying to "reconnect" with his roots. I know where my roots are and they are on the east coast of USA. Why should I feel lesser somehow for admitting that?
all that said,
I enjoyed his other points. He comes across as intelligent and willing to take a stand on issues. I really did resonate with his point about the alt-right: Stop hiding behind avatars and take a stand, be a person instead of a frog meme.
I'd be willing to watch more discussions involving this guy. Roosh, you should reach out to him and do a youtube video or something.