[WestIndianArchie]

You're at your favorite venue.
You're wearing your favorite stuff.
Your game is on 110%

You see 2 chicks
- Abigail - is hot as all get out. Fits whatever it is you like to a T
- Beatrice - is no slouch, she's attractive, but not nearly as fine as Abigail

You approach, they open nicely,
- Abigail is pleasant, but a little quiet/shy, not really as chatty and happy as Beatrice
- Beatrice - you're vibing with her very well.

The menage is not an option (buncha cheeky bastards, I know how you think)

In my experience, I usually go for the personality mesh. But I'm starting to think i'm taking the easy way out.

What situation pushes you to go for the hot chick Abigail who's a little cold? Where you might lose the good chick, Beatrice?

WIA

[LaserBear]

I try to always go with the better odds option. Abigail will remember me leaving with that girl she thought she's cuter than after talking to her, and hopefully this will plant a seed of doubt in her ego that may grow into an easy lay for me later.
Either way I got Beatrice, and that's a success even if I hate that name haha

[Sombro]

Take whatever is easiest at the time. Another day, another woman.

[soup]

Game 101:

Go for the most obvious, most likely to succeed option for whatever situation you are in.

[Comte De St. Germain]

I have a pride problem with this issue. If I'm blue balling easy one for sure, but if I'm not it's always the higher quality one. I always aim for the hottest girl I see and won't move on until it's clear she doesn't like me(screw Game101 in this situation).

[Courage Reborn]

I used to go for the bird in the hand in these situations.

Nowadays I prefer to hail mary for the glory.

I don't win as often this way. But I sleep better at night un-tormented by what could have been. Plus some next level victories to show for it.

[Christian McQueen]

"What situation pushes you to go for the hot chick Abigail who's a little cold? Where you might lose the good chick, Beatrice?"

Who says you can't have both and I don't mean a 3sum...

I would isolate the less attractive girl, number close and plan to meet her later in the night.

Then snag the hotter one and bounce. If the hotter one shoots me down I still have a backup.

What happens if the cute girl sees me go after the hotter one?

I may 'lose' her, but generally that doesn't happen. What happens is the Competitive Hamster kicks in and she tries harder to close me. If the hotter one sees this she just sees that I'm on demand which only helps.

If the hotter shoots me down and the cute girl is pissed, then I 'lose' both, but no risk equals no reward.

One of my favorite player pastimes is to invite multiple girls to meet me out who I've fucked and some I haven't, doesn't matter and see what happens.

It's like my own Elimidate. I should drop a data sheet on these stories.

[Skotch]

(02-18-2014 12:09 AM)soup Wrote:  

Game 101:

Go for the most obvious, most likely to succeed option for whatever situation you are in.

I have trouble with this. I've blown myself out many times going for the higher level target. A few times I've improved my catch, but it definitely backfires more often than not.

Something else to keep in mind.

[spalex]

Naturally, most guys will go for the sure thing.

But shit is getting so repetitive lately, so a challenge seems like a more interesting idea.

[AneroidOcean]

My type is fairly unique, not because I'm some girl snob, but because I tend to like fairly attractive/in shape girls with a nerdy/dorky/reserved side.

I would vastly prefer to go for my type. Sure it's nice if an "attractive" girl is into me, but if there's opportunity I'd much rather get the number from the attractive girl that's into me and have that as a backup, then focus all energy on isolating the one that's my type but being a little shy/reserved (since this actually plays into what I consider my type as well.

Trust me, I like a girl that can open up and be very silly/comfortable letting go and such, but in my favorite venue for night game (I don't even know what I would consider my favorite venue for day game unless it's the beach), my "type" wouldn't necessarily be SUPER outgoing either, unless she was with her friends and then would be outgoing moreso with them, not towards random guys.

(02-18-2014 12:35 AM)Christian McQueen Wrote:  

It's like my own Elimidate. I should drop a data sheet on these stories.

Please do, especially with some backstory so we see what kinds of girls that you date that would do this. I've been in situations where I thought MAYBE I could pull this off, but haven't done it, thinking that these girls were casual, but not casual enough to have their ASD not kick in.

[BlurredLines]

I cockblock myself far too often with this sort of scenario. Always go for the hot one, even if she's clearly not DTF. I don't know why but i can't help myself with quality. I'm sure it's an ego thing...
McQueens get the less hot ones number first is how i'd usually try to play it.. if i can distract myself away from the hotter one long enough.

[aphelion]

Beatrice all day. Vibe is really important to me.

[Mujeriego]

I'll take the sure thing. I've gone home empty handed plenty of times by getting greedy. I like McQueen's idea about isolating the less hot one and grabbing her number as a back up then going for gold with the hot one.

[Slim Shady]

Depends on weather or not I've taken my estrogen pill that day.

[Suits]

Once they are at least a 7, I could really care less about exactly how beautiful she is. I select for girls that I might want to introduce into my soft-harem.

SO, I'd go with the girl that I had an instant vibe with. Looks are important up to a point, but I also require someone to be good company and instantly recognize the quality that I offer.

[Onto]

I would go for Abagail, but I'm a gambler by nature. Always buying and pressing the 4's and 10's at the craps table or hoping to pull an inside straight on the river.

[StrengthBySonny]

If you're goal is to get laid, go with the one who is more down/you vibe with better.

[Travesty]

I'd do it the other way around...

Tell the hot one I am leaving, grab her number after I have the cute one ready to leave. Try to make sure the hot one sees me leave with the cute one.

Try to lower the hot one's self confidence by instilling some doubt about her attractiveness.

Make sure she sees me grinning and grabbing the cute girl's ass on the way out.

[Bacchus]

My answer is that it really depends.

If I'm feeling that I've got a hot hand (i.e. I've pulled something new in the past few days), I'll take more risks and go for the prettier girl, Abby.

In any other situation, I'll go for the girl that seems more into me, Beatrice.