Quote: (03-25-2019 11:30 PM)StrikeBack Wrote:
Usually when he's asked about his criticism of the radical left, he often cites the history of the 20th century (communism) as his objection.
JP hardly ever mentions the alt right in his lectures or interviews, unless someone specifically asks him about them.
I have a feeling that his critics, including this fellow Jan Irvin (never heard of him) never actually watch or read anything JP produces. It's all soundbites and gossips they're quoting.
I'm already on record as saying his psychology stuff is great but anything of his related remotely to politics is generic boomer basic-bitch bullshit.
Unfortunately in this social environment he's determined that the bulk of his celebri-bucks are going to come from politics so AFAIC the bulk of his message is
generic boomer basic-bitch bullshit.
He chose this.
Is Joe Rogan a great fighter? Undoubtedly. He competed at high levels. On the other hand IMO he's a mediocre drugged out radio host
at best who's allowed to keep his platform because the powers that be are invested in using him as a line of demarcation between acceptable and unacceptable content.
You could say "Joe Rogan is a great man, he fought tons of dudes and won a lot of the time", and I'd reply "sure, but now he's chosen to become a mediocre drugged out radio host and as such that's what I define him as".
So when you say "Jordan Peterson is a great clinical psychologist" I'll say "sure, but now he's chosen to become a generic basic-bitch boomer political commentator who's allowed to keep his platform because the powers that be are invested in using him as a line of demarcation between acceptable and unacceptable content, and as such that's what I define him as."
He chose the dirty path of political hot-topics to reach for celebrity instead of sticking to what he was good at, and now that he's lost his grip on the tiger's tail he gets the teeth like everyone else.
Tough shit. If people call him a gutless faggot for any number of perfectly valid reasons then he can cry himself to sleep on his big pile of money. He doesn't need you to shield him with your fandom.
edit: Looking back, how much of this thread is just a ridiculous debate on the un-debatable? Peterson is great on psychology and a moronic boomer when it comes to politics.
These things are not mutually exclusive.