Quote: (08-13-2014 02:05 AM)speakeasy Wrote:
Quote: (08-13-2014 01:35 AM)HeyPete Wrote:
Quote: (08-13-2014 12:54 AM)speakeasy Wrote:
Quote: (08-13-2014 12:45 AM)HeyPete Wrote:
Quote: (08-13-2014 12:39 AM)speakeasy Wrote:
Just a few points, a huge proportion of us did not grow up in neighborhoods like this. There's been a black middle class for some time. I just want to make sure you realize that you are talking about a segment of underclass black society, not our entire group. I've long said that unfortunately, the black middle class is largely invisible to many people. It's people like these rioters that are what you see on the news. I go to the main park in my city on Sundays and I see black middle class families everywhere with their kids and having picnics and BBQs after church and enjoying their lives. Let's not paint the entire black race in a broad brush. I tire of that.
Also, let's not continue this narrative of blacks = welfare while immigrants are hard working. There's a lot of myth in that. For example, Blacks, whites and Hispanics use the same percentage of welfare. Blacks have actually been moving off welfare while Hispanic use is trending up. Look at the chart below. Statistics don't always support the stereotype, in this case, the hard working Hispanics vs lazy blacks looking for handouts.
I get what you are saying about the black middle class. But that chart is utter crap.
Hispanics can be Puerto Rican or Dominican or Mexican or Guatemalan or Bolivian etc. and they are all lumped together to make this huge number. So, if they were separate like it should be, the number would be nowhere close to blacks when it comes to welfare.
Well that's me saying the black number is inaccurate because it lumps together black Americans, Haitian immigrants, African immigrants, Somali refugees, etc.
It wouldn't change the per capita welfare rate. It doesn't matter if the Hispanics come from different countries. All that matters is per capita rate.
So, I guess congratulations are in order since after 300 years blacks are finally, albeit modestly, lowering their welfare numbers. And they've been speaking English, sort of, for all that time.
It's amazing that it only took 10 times the amount of time to do what non-English speakers already accomplished.
I'll see if the government will give you a $100.
Why are you being a smart ass? We don't need to go back 300 years. My parents were alive when blacks couldn't even vote or go to school in some states. This isn't ancient history, they can tell me the stories as they lived through it.
And if it weren't for blacks fighting for civil rights you immigrants would've never even been given a chance to come here as non-white immigration was mostly banned prior to the civil rights movement.
You're an elder statesman on RVF and I enjoy this forum immensely, so I will rightly give you respect as an individual. But the immigrant side of my family didn't need anything from and owes blacks absolutely nothing. The US border jumped them, not the other way around. Their land was stolen, all of it and everything on it in the early 1900's.
They didn't riot. They didn't loot. They rolled up their sleeves and starting building again within a new set of rules.
They too were discriminated against. But they didn't use it as an excuse to give up for generations and generations. My parents, well my Dad, can tell me stories about not being allowed in restaurants. Not being able to use drinking fountains, or stay in certain hotels etc. This wasn't black exclusive. So don't go around patting yourself on the back because Martin Luther King went for a stroll in Alabama.