Posts: 224
Threads: 0
Joined: Mar 2013
Why does Socialism work in a place like Germany but not the US?
04-14-2013, 09:25 PM
In Europe, where nations are generally homogenous culturally and ethnically relative to the US, people are more altruistic and open to redistributive social policies like health care, social security, welfare, etc. People in these countries are more pro-social and trusting both toward their own people and toward foreigners than they would be if these same people were in more multicultural environments. Europeans and Americans have different histories and culture, so homogeneity/diversity will have different outcomes, but all things being equal, this is the general tendency.
This isn’t to say that Europeans are more foreigner-friendly than Americans (in fact, the opposite is probably closer to the truth due to the cultural differences between the US and Europe), but that there’s a vibe of instant familiarity in Europe that makes certain social programs more appealing.
As the number of foreigners increase, however, people begin trading the team approach for greater individualism. This is happening not only in Europe, but also with white-Americans, who are increasingly drifting toward the Republican party.
Posts: 35
Threads: 0
Joined: Jan 2013
Reputation:
1
Why does Socialism work in a place like Germany but not the US?
04-16-2013, 08:26 AM
Germans, while different culturally from Greeks, Italians, Spanish ecc would probably adapt in a similar way to the Mediterranean countries if they were put in a Mediterranean framework/legal system. I was born and raised in Berlin and grew up between the US/Italian/German worlds. What happens if you put a German in a Southern European system, do they continue to be upright and law abiding or do they play the local game? ---> I think you'll see 9 times out of 10 that they play the local game. Friends of mine do.
The fundamental difference is the system of laws. Italian laws for example are theoretically beautiful but practically nightmarish. No attention is paid to the application in the real flawed world we live in. The laws are beautiful in their intentions and unrealistic and often inapplicable. Greece I don't know well but when I was there for a short period there were a lot of games going on. Games within games. If you're stupid enough not to see everything then you should be screwed was often the prevalent view I saw there.
Posts: 4,676
Threads: 0
Joined: Feb 2012
Reputation:
0
Why does Socialism work in a place like Germany but not the US?
04-16-2013, 03:56 PM
The difference is that the German is a real barbarian who has no problem to press for the application of law.They do not chew iron as we say here.The Southerners especially the Italians are way too scared to complain against the big men who run the situations.Not so the Germans.The Germans are fearless it is a national trait.They always laugh at Italians how easily they get scared.
Posts: 1,019
Threads: 0
Joined: Oct 2011
Reputation:
26
Why does Socialism work in a place like Germany but not the US?
04-18-2013, 01:59 AM
Quote: (04-10-2013 03:00 PM)kerouac Wrote:
Why is it that labor unions are more effective in Germany? Why is infrastructure better off in Germany? Why is health care better in Germany?
In recession battle, Germany and China are winners
Why all this from a country that is much more Socialistic than the United States? Is Germany just less corrupt by nature? What is it about Germany?
Quote:Quote:
Most Americans, I suspect, believe we’re losing manufacturing because we can’t compete against cheap Chinese labor. But Germany has remained a manufacturing giant notwithstanding the rise of East Asia, making high-end products with a workforce that is more unionized and better paid than ours. German exports came to $1.1 trillion in 2009 — roughly $125 billion more than we exported, though there are just 82 million Germans to our 310 million Americans. Germany’s yearly trade balance went from a deficit of $6 billion in 1998 to a surplus of $267 billion in 2008 — the same year the United States ran a trade deficit of $569 billion. Over those same 10 years, Germany’s annual growth rate per capita exceeded ours.
Germany has increased its edge in world-class manufacturing even as we have squandered ours because its model of capitalism is superior to our own. For one thing, its financial sector serves the larger economy, not just itself. The typical German company has a long-term relationship with a single bank — and for the smaller manufacturers that are the backbone of the German economy, those relationships are likely with one of Germany’s 431 savings banks, each of them a local institution with a municipally appointed board, that shun capital markets and invest their depositors’ savings in upgrading local enterprises. By American banking standards, the savings banks are incredibly dull. But they didn’t lose money in the financial panic of 2008 and have financed an industrial sector that makes ours look anemic by comparison.
http://benjamindavidsteele.wordpress.com...t-germany/
I'd Like to choose.... What is the "US Postal Service" for 300 Alex.
"All My Bitches love me....I love all my bitches,
but its like soon as I cum... I come to my senses."
Posts: 224
Threads: 0
Joined: Feb 2013
Reputation:
2
Why does Socialism work in a place like Germany but not the US?
04-24-2013, 09:24 AM
1.Germany has a smaller population than the US, Social services are more efficient for countries with lower population.
2.It is a social market economy, there's a reason why Michael Moore didn't visit Germany for his movie 'Sicko'.
3.There are also other differences, Germans are healthier than Americans, well, what about calorie intake?, Germans are better educated, well, different demographics.
I'll make this simple, Germany is more efficient, simply because it's full of Germans, and I hope those guys that are commenting about WW2 aren't serious, if anything.
1.Germany was vastly outnumbered in that war, 10 to 1, I'd like to know how they'd do in a 10 to 1 fight.
2.Germany didn't have an air force in 1933, and by 1945, they were flying the first operational jet fighters.
3.Best infantry, best officers, and best tactics.
Erich Von Manstein, It is said that the guy killed thousands of NKVD pricks, is it true?