Honestly go with the one you have the best shot with... but if all else equal, the mediocre one will be more enjoyable. You will probably last longer. There's a lot of mental handicaps early on in a man's sexual adventures and it could be over faster than you'd like it to be especially with the hot one. Either way make sure you go for rounds 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6. The more experience early on the better.
Vice-Captain - #TeamWaitAndSee