Quote: (11-16-2011 08:20 PM)americanInEurope Wrote:
Quote: (11-16-2011 07:57 PM)nomadicdude Wrote:
So I'm not familiar with the German education system but the sorta caste system you are describing in Germany is basically what you have in America. People who are rich attend $30,000+ a year private schools from the time they are five years old. I went to a pretty prestigious graduate school on the east coast and 75% of the kids had gone to these prep schools their whole lives. I went to public schools my whole life and had never realized how skewed toward the rich the top universities are in this country. It certainly is not a real meritocracy.
The difference is, if you went to a preppy grad school and I only went to John Jacob Jingleheimer Schmidt University for my undergrad, but if I've got more experience and certifications than you I'm getting more money than you. Or at least the same. Rarely does a prestigious university count significantly in America. Maybe JD's, MD's or MBA's, but everything else I don't think so. Especially not in IT. In Germany it's 100% about what you have on that paper. No matter if you can do the job better than the next guy or not.
Love this thread, just wanted to add a quick response to this.
nomadicdude is dead on with his characterization of the school system's economic picture. I'm at an Ivy now and I can tell you that there is very little socio-economic diversity here. Representatives of elite Boston suburbs, Westchester County(NY) and Fairfield County(CT) seem to punch way above their demographic weight. The vast majority of the students here are, at a bare minimum, solidly upper middle class. I'm willing to bet that if you got financial aid to open the books, you'd see very few total household incomes below $150-250k. This place IS the 1%.
That being said, I myself am living proof of the meritocracy you're talking about. I've been lower middle class(and, on occasion, downright poor) for most of my life here in the USA. Yet here I am, a middling black kid at arguably the best undergrad in the country, taking advantage of absolutely tremendous resources and opportunities, paying next to no tuition for the privilege, and going head-to-head with kids who had far more resources and preparation than I ever did, and beating them academically to boot in most cases (judging by my grades).
Granted, kids of my lower socio-economic status are rare on my campus, but I have had tremendous opportunity here. I'm pretty hard on the USA in many ways (especially the dating, culture and the racial baggage the country has), but I'll give credit where it is due. America has given me every opportunity to succeed on my own merits, and to subsequently compete at and elevate myself to the very highest level, despite coming from a place far below that.
I will say this, though: prestigous university degrees
do count here. There is absolutely no question about that. The effect is not as massive as some portray, but it is very, very significant. There are some lucrative careers that you simply cannot break into without a degree from a top undergrad (Ivy, Little Ivy, Stanford, Duke, etc). In more technical fields, though (ex: engineering, IT), it does matter much less.