[MOVSM]

Thriving on raw eggs, world's oldest person marks 117th birthday in Italy

Quote:

"When I first knew her she used to eat three eggs a day. Two raw, and one fried. Today she has slowed down a bit, reducing the number to two some days because she says three can be too much," her doctor Carlo Bava told Reuters TV.

"She has never eaten much fruit or vegetables. Her characteristic is that she always eats the same thing, every day, every week, every month and every year."

...but I think she's lying.

Three Extra Large Grade AA Eggs are 240 kCal.

Inputting her information in a calculator, and I'm taking assumptions per her height/weight--I will use 4'11" and 75lbs with body fat 12%--I'm going for bare minimum here. She is completely sedentary woman who was born on 11/29/1899.
We get base metabolic rate of 540 kCal per day. She needs 595 kCal per day to not lose weight!

She says she lived like this all her life, and I fail to see how. On the surface it looks good--low carb diet, raw food so the nutrients are not leeched out, etc.
But numbers are not there to sustain her to even sit on her ass.

Thoughts?

[Simeon_Strangelight]

Metabolics are going up and down tremendously. All those calculations are usually only more or less right - they err however sometimes 600-900 calories. It can be done since her body metabolizes not only the fat of her eggs, but also her own fat. But of course she will have days where she eats much more than that.

[MOVSM]

(11-29-2016 06:02 PM)Zelcorpion Wrote:  

It can be done since her body metabolizes not only the fat of her eggs, but also her own fat.

If she lived like this her entire life, she doesn't have the fat stores to sustain her into her 100's.

Quote:

But of course she will have days where she eats much more than that.

That's not what the article (and her doctor) claims. Though this is what I suspect, thus making her story a lie.

[Simeon_Strangelight]

Buddy - nowhere in the article is said that she lives ONLY ON 3 EGGS A DAY. It is only stated that she eats 3 eggs a day which the current medical scam-idiocracy establishment considers "unbalanced". Of course in our circles we know that it is quite healthy and likely the reason she is still alive. We can also assume that she may have her own hens or has it from someone she knows - quasi organic or above organic.

The lowest you can get in terms of calories is this, but that guy also eats high potency supplements and protein concentrate powder while keeping a calorie restriction diet. Without the protein concentrate and supplements he would be unhealthy. The woman eats certainly other things as well - she is in Italy and they always eat for various occasions.

That guy eats roughly 1300-1400 calories which is possible with the calorie restriction model and also due to him getting nutrients in a concentrated way. He is also a medical doctor specializing in ageing research.

[renotime]

She lives in Italy. She probably covers it in half a gallon of olive oil.

[The Beast1]

Or instead of arguing amongst ourselves, there's a high probability the journalist who wrote the article got it wrong entirely and she eats other things during the day. We won't know.

@Zep, lol come on man. Amen Ra is 5ft 6 and has a very tiny frame. He's in manlet territorty.

[philosophical_recovery]

(11-30-2016 09:09 AM)The Beast1 Wrote:  

Or instead of arguing amongst ourselves, there's a high probability the journalist who wrote the article got it wrong entirely and she eats other things during the day. We won't know.

@Zep, lol come on man. Amen Ra is 5ft 6 and has a very tiny frame. He's in manlet territorty.

Clearly you don't understand vegan powers:

[ScrapperTL]

(11-30-2016 09:40 AM)philosophical_recovery Wrote:  

(11-30-2016 09:09 AM)The Beast1 Wrote:  

Or instead of arguing amongst ourselves, there's a high probability the journalist who wrote the article got it wrong entirely and she eats other things during the day. We won't know.

@Zep, lol come on man. Amen Ra is 5ft 6 and has a very tiny frame. He's in manlet territorty.

Clearly you don't understand vegan powers:

Haha, I try my best not to watch too much modern garbage television but this scene always cracks me up.
Also hilarious when Chris Evans shouts "It's called a Grind BRO!"

[Simeon_Strangelight]

Yeah - that is why Amun Ra is the world record holder in deadlift - short guys have an advantage.

Of course if he were 6'4, then he would likely need 2200 calories for the same restriction diet, but my argument remains.

Funny vid about "vegan power".

I have come to the realization that you can probably survive on all three methods of eating - paleo, vegetarian or vegan because we have access to specialized foods now, year round fruit and vegetables and also supplements and protein powders.

But paleo is probably still the most tasty healthy diet.

The grandma above survived on 3 raw eggs and likely very little food - all folk above 100 have this in common. They eat rather little, have intermittent fasting (often 16 hours without food incl. sleep) and they have some kind of high-nutrient food intake. Nowadays you have high quality supplements as well to aid in that.

Amun Ra should probably become 100+ easily if he sticks to his regimen.



Here test results from mice on life extension - low calories, but full nutrients.

There is already a society that is doing that in real life, but most there look like wimps. At least Amun Ra is jacked - even if he is short, but that is not his fault.
http://www.crsociety.org/

[The Beast1]

I'm going to stick with my previous assumption that we're not getting a complete picture of the 100 year old grandma and of Amen Ra.

I'd go so far to say that Amen Ra's secret is a heavy dose of vitamin S and the old woman has good genetics.

[Simeon_Strangelight]

(11-30-2016 11:38 AM)The Beast1 Wrote:  

I'm going to stick with my previous assumption that we're not getting a complete picture of the 100 year old grandma and of Amen Ra.

I'd go so far to say that Amen Ra's secret is a heavy dose of vitamin S and the old woman has good genetics.

Vitamin S as in sperm? He has a white wife for 20 years. The guy is in his early 40s or end 30s now. He has the hallmarks of an introverted silent guy, but his face lights up when he looks at his wife. Doubt he is gay. No reason to cover that up in our time.

But as I said before - his diet would be impossible without modern supplements and amino-acid concentrates.



Well - she probably has a personality that fits him and I certainly hope so for his sake.

[The Beast1]

(11-30-2016 11:47 AM)Zelcorpion Wrote:  

(11-30-2016 11:38 AM)The Beast1 Wrote:  

I'm going to stick with my previous assumption that we're not getting a complete picture of the 100 year old grandma and of Amen Ra.

I'd go so far to say that Amen Ra's secret is a heavy dose of vitamin S and the old woman has good genetics.

Vitamin S as in sperm? He has a white wife for 20 years. The guy is in his early 40s now. He has the hallmarks of an introverted silent guy, but his face lights up when he looks at his wife. Doubt he is gay. No reason to cover that up in our time.

But as I said before - his diet would be impossible without modern supplements and amino-acid concentrates.

Yeah dude, vitamin S! Eating vitamin S keeps your vitality and test up! Ancient greeks did it too!

Vitamin S(teroids) - this is what I was insinuating.

Agree with you on the 2nd bit absolutetly!

[MOVSM]

(11-30-2016 04:53 AM)Zelcorpion Wrote:  

nowhere in the article is said that she lives ONLY ON 3 EGGS A DAY.
...
The woman eats certainly other things as well - she is in Italy and they always eat for various occasions.

I you take that reading, yes, I can see. That is not even implied in the article however. But with current state of journalism I'm not surprised.

So at very best, there is a vastly incomplete picture of the affair.

It would be interesting to see if her doctor published a study on her.

[Simeon_Strangelight]

(11-30-2016 11:53 AM)The Beast1 Wrote:  

Yeah dude, vitamin S! Eating vitamin S keeps your vitality and test up! Ancient greeks did it too!

Vitamin S(teroids) - this is what I was insinuating.

Agree with you on the 2nd bit absolutetly!

Heh - yeah possible use of steroids, but he did take part in a ADFPF – American Drug Free Powerlifting Federation - competition.

And they do test, so somehow I doubt it - also he would have little reason to juice or even to lie. If he were 6'5, then he would be much less massive looking. Short guys can sometimes look quite bulky if they work out heavily - his training regimen consists of daily lifting - 7 days a week for years with few breaks.

I think that is rather more a very disciplined bloke - those exist.

[Praetor Lupus]

WNB.

[Fortis]

I might believe the old woman's story. It seems as though people who don't eat a lot live longer than hogs. She probably eats more or less on some days. No one is always eating the same thing all the time. The assume as much is bonkers.

Ra seems cool, but his personality seems like quite an affectation. I was cringing when I heard him speak. Either way, good for him for pulling 600 pounds at his weight and good on him for WALKING the walk instead of being that doctor who tells you "eat healthy, lift weights and sleep a lot" without doing any of that. Also, good on him for being with a woman he seems to enjoy being with.

I Don't quite believe his story about 1,3000 calories but he looks youthful as fuck, so Who knows? Either way, I'd love to know what his steroid stack is. He has gyno (man boobs). That seems a bit unusual for a guy who is really on a super low-calorie diet.

[roberto]

(11-30-2016 06:22 PM)Fortis Wrote:  

I might believe the old woman's story. It seems as though people who don't eat a lot live longer than hogs.

There have been various studies into this which suggest there is more than a grain of truth here.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Calorie_restriction