Are you sure the initial interaction went as good as you think it did or did you mistake her for just being friendly?
Your very first text was the "lighter hostage" one? Others may disagree with me but that just seems a little corny to me out of the gate. Also not sure if were missing texts you sent but every one you listed just makes you seem a little weird. i.e. lighter hostage, pirates, devastating charm.
As far as immediate recovery goes it sounds a bit difficult what I would do is continue playing on the soccer team and try to smash the other hot girls on the team you mentioned. If you can get some other girls on the team attracted to you that could change the way in which she sees you.
Your very first text was the "lighter hostage" one? Others may disagree with me but that just seems a little corny to me out of the gate. Also not sure if were missing texts you sent but every one you listed just makes you seem a little weird. i.e. lighter hostage, pirates, devastating charm.
As far as immediate recovery goes it sounds a bit difficult what I would do is continue playing on the soccer team and try to smash the other hot girls on the team you mentioned. If you can get some other girls on the team attracted to you that could change the way in which she sees you.