It depends why you want the shirts. If you want them for work, you would be better off with something more subdued. If you want shirts for going out or casual wear, wear what you personally find attractive and comfortable on your body. Clothing snobs aren't always good looking, sociable, or even well dressed, and you have no idea who's commenting on a style forum. Could be the lamest people in the universe, could be Alexander McQueen.
No harm in a little contrast...it's not like you'd be wearing Ed Hardy.
No harm in a little contrast...it's not like you'd be wearing Ed Hardy.