Quote: (01-14-2013 01:05 PM)wi30 Wrote:
Quote: (01-13-2013 11:52 PM)kosko Wrote:
Off what, one game? There is a reason Flynn got whipped around in Training Camp by Wilson. Cousins in Washington at least won a game and came back in another for a win. Flynn had one amazing performance in a game that did not matter vs Detroit which by next season will be almost 2 years ago.
Wilson would have beat out a majority of quarterbacks around the league. He is the type of QB that you can build a franchise around. But Flynn is completely capable of being a starter. You're right that he hasn't had the chance to prove himself but Seattle gave him a huge contract because of that Detroit game. There are teams that would benefit by putting him in the starting role.
I'm not sure that the thinking has completely changed just yet. Teams are still afraid of smaller athletes at the position. It all depends on who the coaches and coordinators are. Pete Carroll isn't afraid of going against the grain, and was willing to tailor his offense to the particular skills of his QB. It was unprecedented for him to choose Wilson over Flynn because they had just signed Flynn to a huge free agent contract, and Flynn had more experience, even if he'd only had a couple of starts. He'd been in the league a little while, went through practices, etc. etc. which is also valuable. Most coaches would have still gone with the veteran they had made the financial investment in, even though the rook had better preseason numbers. It may have made the leash a little shorter for the veteran starter, but the vet would have gotten the benefit of the doubt.
The rookie year successes of Matt Ryan and Joe Flacco opened eyes, in that it wasn't impossible to have success with a rookie starter IF you have a solid veteran roster and a good running game. Mark Sanchez came a year later, and his team got to two straight conference championship games. Now, other organizations aren't as uncomfortable making that move if they don't have a better veteran option. Teams that have the opportunity to pick QBs high in the first round are bad teams, so you don't lose a lot by letting him take his lumps early. Also, more QBs are running pro-style offenses in college, and even high school. They're more prepared to step in and run these offenses because they've seen and run similar. It's just a matter of terminology now. Guys like Newton, RGIII, and Kaepernick are introducing a new model for the position, in that they have strong, accurate arms, AND they are not just mobile, but taking off on
designed running plays (you still don't want to get your QB hit this much though). I don't see Russell Wilson as a runner - he's a mobile,
scrambling QB that can extend plays and find open receivers, but can tuck it and gain yardage if necessary. They don't really design runs for Wilson.
What Jim Harbaugh did was truly unprecedented. He replaced a successful veteran starter (he'd taken them to the NFC title game the year before, and was statistically at the top of the league among QBs this season) who was out injured with a young QB that hadn't started a game. That is against the unwritten code, but he was a player that could do everything the other QB could do, AND had the added dimension of being a runner with a stronger arm. Tom Brady showed many that you can find a successful QB outside of the first round (Brady was a 6th rounder, Wilson was a 3rd rounder), and Kaepernick (2nd rounder) shows that your QB doesn't have to come from one of the top football factories. It's about the skills and smarts of the particular player, and not necessarily where he played or who he played against on the college level. If the kid is a great athlete, he'll create problems for defenses. For the most part, GMs and coaches will still lean towards the 6'3" pocket passer with the strong arm, because that's still what most are comfortable with. Every now and then a large, mobile athlete comes along and it's a no-brainer. Still, for anyone that doesn't fit that mold, there's still lots of hand-wringing among personnel people in the NFL.