Quote: (07-22-2014 10:10 PM)Menace Wrote:
Great documentary. One thing I don't like is how food is treated as too big of an event, and the concern with authenticity, and the "culturification" of it all. And I feel like I'm falling into that trap because now I know where this food can be found.
Valid points, and common ones in the food world.
There are pros and cons to this explosion of interest in the food world, specifically in America.
Most obviously, our bitches are too fat and having all this incredible food isn't helping them out. It's also an extremely shallow pursuit.
On the other hand, it's hard to complain when food goes from canned mushrooms in the 70s to having fresh mushrooms available in any store now. Whatever your taste, it's out there. And the quality has skyrocketed. Every year, there's a growing market of grassroots food suppliers that are bringing high quality products to consumers, and this isn't a bad thing.
As far as authenticity goes, this is a classic debate amongst chefs. There are various cultures that are obsessed with the notion of authenticity, and I always use Italy as an example because nearly every Italian I've met buys into the idea that authentic=better. There is perhaps no ingredient that is more synonymous with Italian food as the tomato, and yet it's only been there for a few hundred years. In fact, many staples in Europe were brought from the new world, so what does authenticity mean within that context? If food is always evolving, how can there be "authentic"?
And yet, I know where he's coming from. When chefs like Andy Ricker talk about authenticity, it's not necessarily to reference the way things have always been done. It's authentic to his experience. He ate a certain thing, and his goal was to recreate it as accurately as possible. For me, this is incredibly admirable, especially in contrast to every other Top Chef jackass that insists on going on and on about "their" food and "their" ideas, even though they're stealing shit that's been done for years. Ricker has the humility to say, "This isn't about me, it's about them." He sees himself as more of an ambassador and doesn't think to dilute something that's already good with some notion of "fusion".