Quote: (12-07-2013 05:55 AM)houston Wrote:
Cardguy do you think you should ALWAYS get the originals?
I am no expert. But this has become a big issue from about the mid nineties onwards.
So - if you have an album that came out before that - I would stick with that instead of getting a later reissue.
The history of recorded sound (and the records vs CDs debates and so on) is a really complex one. But also very interesting. This is a great book which goes over the history of all the major issues (including the problem of modern re-issues):
http://www.amazon.co.uk/Perfecting-Sound...ding+sound
Personally - I must be weird. I actually think cassette tapes sound better than CDs, MP3s and records. I feel the sound is warmer but also more vivid at the same time. And I like the way the subtle warping of the tape changes the sound over time.
I dunno' if this is a good example. Here are a couple of my favourite songs that I listen to alot on YouTube. And they are both taken from cassettes. It is amazing how good they sound - and to me they sound better than any other format.
I have listened to these songs on CDs and MP3s and they don't sound as good as this. I have a bunch of other cassette tapes where the songs sound better in that format than they do on CD or record as well.
But it all depends. One of my favourite albums is 'Astral Weeks' by Van Morrison - and that sounds much better on record. Particularly on large speakers which allow the sound to move through the room. It is a complex album - and you hear different instruments/melodies everytime you listen to it.
But the debate is alargely academic. Since the sound engineers who mix he album have a much bigger impact than the choice of format you ultimately decide to use to listen to the music on.