Quote: (12-03-2013 04:29 AM)Athlone McGinnis Wrote:
Quote: (12-03-2013 03:05 AM)speakeasy Wrote:
Even though there's good music from other countries too, especially Latin America, there's no question that the US and UK absolutely crush the rest of the world in musical innovation and leading trends. If you made a list of the 50 best bands in history, 90% of them would be from either the US or UK, which is remarkable considering that there are 300 other countries and we only make up a combined 6% or so of the global population.
Second to colonialism, I think the success of US/UK music is why English is so widely understood around the world. Yet many think these two countries are culturally devoid.
My answer? African-Americans.
African Americans are a musically gifted population. They are pretty much responsible for creating Jazz, Blues and Rock & Roll, genres that form the basis for most of the popular music across the globe in the recent past and in the present. The Jamaicans are the ones who can take credit for Hip-Hop and Reggae, but even those had some strong jazz influences. Most of the most iconic British musicians (ex: The Beatles) took their influences directly from African-Americans or indirectly from musical forms (ex: Rock and Roll) that had been created by African Americans.
To put it simply, African-Americans have a freakish ability to regularly produce musical sounds/styles that resonate on a global scale with people of just about every background. I'm not sure there's another group in recent history that has managed to wield and spread that much global cultural influence without employing any of the traditional means of spreading that influence (ex: no colonialism, no armies, no real legal compulsion, etc, etc). Even people who generally had no love for African Americans and/or not contact with them (ex: White Americans who embraced Rock and Roll in the mid 20th Century, modern East Asians who've embraced jazz/funk/pop/rap in their mainstream music, etc) seem unable to resist mimicking them. Their culture is just magnetic.
I think its the presence of this particularly musically gifted population in the USA that has helped that nation dominate the global music scene. The USA is home to arguably the most musically magnetic and innovative population on Earth, and thus tends to lead in that regard.
The UK benefited from its unusually close relationship to the USA (one that facilitated the inspiration and rise of groups like The Beatles) and its possession of arguably the globe's second most musically gifted and magnetic population (Jamaicans). That explains its co-dominance, IMO.
I'd agree it's to do with the Black population (also due to the simple cultural dominance of the US/UK over the last century), but actually for a different reason. I don't think musical "gift" is related to race at all, but the musical heritage black people brought to Europe and the USA was better suited to the changing purposes and market for music.
If you think back 200 years, what was music used for? Ballroom dances, opera, artistic performances that would last 2-4 hours, most of which were largely enjoyed by the upper classes of society. Chamber music was performed by groups of friends in a home setting. The focal point of European classical music was melody, complex harmony and thematic development. The most "popular" music would probably have been the music sung at church.
With the advance of recording technology and the advent of things like the radio and playback devices, music became a commodity for mass consumption. The average person doesn't want to listen to a 2 hour symphony, they want something short and memorable that they can sing along with and that's easy to dance to. In comes the African influence, with a focus on groove and rhythm; instantly marketable, and perfectly suited to settings like bars and clubs. All the businessmen had to do was package it for a black audience, then repackage it for a white audience (lol Elvis) and enjoy the immediate cash flow.
Quote: (12-03-2013 04:33 AM)Windom Earle Wrote:
If we're talking guitar based music, which I guess we are, then acknowledgment has to go to one of the most innovative inventors/designers in the musical instrument industry - Leo Fender... and Les Paul should probably get a mention too.
So, the US had these cutting edge instruments (both guitars and amplifiers) right in their backyard from the outset of rock n roll taking off, which no doubt facilitated experimentation into this new territory. Being a predominantly Anglo pursuit, their UK cousins were putting their own spin on it too. Enter the British Invasion, and a healthy dose of one-upmanship and you've got a recipe for progression and the ongoing creation of "better" music.
Don't forget Robert Moog either! Synths changed the face of modern music probably as much as the guitar.
Quote: (12-03-2013 07:00 AM)Brez Wrote:
Affrican americans musicaly gifted? You think rhyming about popping a cap in my white ass is a gift? They're idiots if anything
Art Tatum, Miles Davis, Herbie Hancock, John Coltrane, B.B. King, Freddie King, Albert King, Jimi Hendrix, Michael Jackson, Prince, Aretha Franklin, Nina Simone, Stevie Wonder, Tosin Abasi, Stanley Jordan... need I go on?