rooshvforum.network is a fully functional forum: you can search, register, post new threads etc...
Old accounts are inaccessible: register a new one, or recover it when possible. x


Fact or Bro-Science?
#1

Fact or Bro-Science?

Guy at my gym told me that not only is it's okay to do a little bit of light cardio after working out but that its actually amazing for weight loss.

This flies in the face of what I [thought I?] knew. I thought that cardio anywhere near your workout was destructive to your gainzzzzz.

Can anyone help shed some light on this?
Reply
#2

Fact or Bro-Science?

I always thought you could do some cardio before lifting with little adverse effect, but that doing it after would hurt gains.

I'm far from being an expert though.

"A flower can not remain in bloom for years, but a garden can be cultivated to bloom throughout seasons and years." - xsplat
Reply
#3

Fact or Bro-Science?

You just have to keep it light otherwise you will go Catabolic. Keep a steady brisk heart rate for 20-30 mins and you will be fine. Cardio at high intensity is actually worse for you in the long run, year your heart will love you for it but it breaks down a lot of other shit on your body long term. A lot of people differ on that point though but as far as gainzzzzz and muscle building you will be okay.

Weight loss is weight loss if your in a deficit you'll be fine. My guess is that people train to hard with weights and then with cardio and never replenish their body enough aside from their body going into a catabolic state. People whom are doing high intensity training like Athletes are eating 5000+ Calories a day. If your in the gym for 2 hours banging out sets and then running a marathon on a treadmill your going to need the same high calorie intakes or else your body will eat away at it's self.
Reply
#4

Fact or Bro-Science?

I have come to the conclusion that it's different for everybody, but there's a general consensus. What will kill your gains (cardio wise) is jogging. After two months of jogging I found that my pulling strength overall went completely to shit. I also did not lose any bodyfat.

This is also consistent with my performance in the gym during rugby season. Nearly all of my numbers go down, particularly in the squat and deadlift. I don't think this can be purely attributed to missing workouts either, whenever I just take a break from weightlifting and do absolutely nothing my numbers don't go down as badly.

I recommend giving it a shot for two months and recording your progress. I also recommend doing any kind of cardio that is not jogging. Maybe a long walk or short sprints, or jumping rope.
Reply
#5

Fact or Bro-Science?

It's fine to do some light cardio after a weight session.

I used to see a lot of jacked guys in the gym ramp up the incline and keep the speed low so it was like a brisk walk.

The idea of getting it in after your session is that your glycogen stores are depleted, therefore your body will be burning fat stores.

Doing cardio, i.e. more than just a warm up before weights will destroy your lifts.

Ever beat your ass in the gym then go for a jog after and sill surprisingly have a fair amount in the tank? That's because it's easier to activate the nervous and energy systems involved in running as opposed to lifting weights.

Our ancestors were long distance athletes, sometimes stalking their prey over long periods so this makes sense.
Reply
#6

Fact or Bro-Science?

Quote: (01-11-2013 03:18 PM)dk902 Wrote:  

Our ancestors were long distance athletes, sometimes stalking their prey over long periods so this makes sense.

Most long distance hunts were apparently accomplished by walking. No one ran long distances.

This conclusion is based on studies done on the few hunter-gatherer societies that were left in the 20th century. These guys walked everywhere.

So I find it hard to believe your conclusion of the ancestral long distance athlete.
Reply
#7

Fact or Bro-Science?

people have already gone over the why they do cardio post wo and the theory behind it....the theory behind not doing it, is it shuts down m-tor...I can't remember the pro that said it now but he's a genius, name is escaping me for some reason it'll come to me at some point... described it to me once this way and it's probably the best way to describe it I could think of... think of working out as stepping on the gas towards muscle building...post wo cardio slams the brakes on that...its hard to know how what level of for how long will shut down m-tor but when Im working out its to build muscle not to burn fat, I save my cardio for morning, do it fasted first thing burn fat....workout I want to build muscle and giving m-tor as much time switched on as possible so I space them out. That's the science behind it but real world practical application...you probably if you took it easy on the cardio, low intensity, wouldn't hurt your results much but Ive gotten into the routine of seperating them and dont find it inconvenient so I just work with the science and if you can I recommend it.
Reply
#8

Fact or Bro-Science?

Agreed, a 10 minute jog after your weights session is fine.
Reply
#9

Fact or Bro-Science?

its straight up broscience about cardio killing gains.il post something better later
Reply
#10

Fact or Bro-Science?

Here's another one: hunger is the feeling of fat leaving your body.

Fact, or bro-science?
Reply
#11

Fact or Bro-Science?

I've never known a person dying of starvation to be fat and I'm sure they're hungry all the time....
Reply
#12

Fact or Bro-Science?

Hunger is your body telling you to jack up it's blood sugar levels. You don't experience "real hunger" until two days after you've last eaten.

It really doesn't matter when you eat, so long as you're getting enough calories. The hodge twins only eat in a 4 hour eating window once a day and they're jacked and shredded to shit.

I wouldn't do cardio just because I detest it. I prefer interval training (like sprints with walking as the rest between sprints), kettlebell swings, burpees, whatever.

I'll link this from Chaos and Pain. Not safe for work. There's a warning before you go to the website, but most people are retarded and can't seem to stop clicking shit.

You have been warned.

http://chaosandpain.blogspot.com/2011/02...logic.html


Quote: (01-11-2013 03:02 PM)kosko Wrote:  

You just have to keep it light otherwise you will go Catabolic. Keep a steady brisk heart rate for 20-30 mins and you will be fine. Cardio at high intensity is actually worse for you in the long run, year your heart will love you for it but it breaks down a lot of other shit on your body long term. A lot of people differ on that point though but as far as gainzzzzz and muscle building you will be okay.


Really? Does high intensity cardio break down your joints or other organs or what?

If that's the case, what form of cardio should I do, if I do any cardio at all?

“I have a very simple rule when it comes to management: hire the best people from your competitors, pay them more than they were earning, and give them bonuses and incentives based on their performance. That’s how you build a first-class operation.”
― Donald J. Trump

If you want some PDF's on bodyweight exercise with little to no equipment, send me a PM and I'll get back to you as soon as possible.
Reply
#13

Fact or Bro-Science?

Quote: (02-01-2013 03:02 PM)TheMan Wrote:  

Here's another one: hunger is the feeling of fat leaving your body.

Fact, or bro-science?

Not really.

http://www.precisionnutrition.com/leptin...eight-loss
Reply
#14

Fact or Bro-Science?

Wearing heavy clothing to the gym (sometimes even with plastic bags wrapped around yourself underneath them) as a way to encourage extra weight loss
Reply
#15

Fact or Bro-Science?

Quote: (02-01-2013 03:19 PM)Hannibal Wrote:  

Hunger is your body telling you to jack up it's blood sugar levels. You don't experience "real hunger" until two days after you've last eaten.

It really doesn't matter when you eat, so long as you're getting enough calories. The hodge twins only eat in a 4 hour eating window once a day and they're jacked and shredded to shit.

I wouldn't do cardio just because I detest it. I prefer interval training (like sprints with walking as the rest between sprints), kettlebell swings, burpees, whatever.

I'll link this from Chaos and Pain. Not safe for work. There's a warning before you go to the website, but most people are retarded and can't seem to stop clicking shit.

You have been warned.

http://chaosandpain.blogspot.com/2011/02...logic.html


Quote: (01-11-2013 03:02 PM)kosko Wrote:  

You just have to keep it light otherwise you will go Catabolic. Keep a steady brisk heart rate for 20-30 mins and you will be fine. Cardio at high intensity is actually worse for you in the long run, year your heart will love you for it but it breaks down a lot of other shit on your body long term. A lot of people differ on that point though but as far as gainzzzzz and muscle building you will be okay.


Really? Does high intensity cardio break down your joints or other organs or what?

If that's the case, what form of cardio should I do, if I do any cardio at all?

More aimed at the person whom runs X-miles per day, everyday, as Joggers tend to develop issues with their joints and cartilage when they grow older. It's just really a matter of stress and impacts tit does to you I've time but the positives are too good to pass up though.

Alternatives:

Ride a bike
Play sports
Swimming
Have more sex

Anything that gets your heart going for 20-30 mins is Cardio. If your looking to loose weight then there is nothing wrong with running for a few months at a high rate abs then just scaling it down to a casual low impact amount after.
Reply
#16

Fact or Bro-Science?

Quote: (01-11-2013 02:49 PM)TheMan Wrote:  

Guy at my gym told me that not only is it's okay to do a little bit of light cardio after working out but that its actually amazing for weight loss.

This flies in the face of what I [thought I?] knew. I thought that cardio anywhere near your workout was destructive to your gainzzzzz.

Can anyone help shed some light on this?
Short of insane genetics or miracle drugs, it is physiologically impossible to gain muscle and lose fat at the same time.
So yes, bro science, ditch the cardio... Unless you're on a cutting cycle.
Reply
#17

Fact or Bro-Science?

First great thread.
What about soy protein raising your estrogen, is that true?
Reply
#18

Fact or Bro-Science?

Quote: (04-03-2013 04:44 AM)CarltonBanks Wrote:  

First great thread.
What about soy protein raising your estrogen, is that true?

Here is an article on the topic with links to scientific studies: http://blog.zocdoc.com/does-soy-feminize...t-vs-myth/

Here is the Mens' Health take on the topic: http://www.menshealth.com/nutrition/soys...lpage=true

My unqualified take: If soy is the only protein source available to you, consume it. As long as you can substitute it with something else, avoid it although infrequent moderate consumption will not kill you. The studies so far indicate a potential positive relation between soy and estrogen levels. Since soy does not have any advantages over other protein sources and food staples, I avoid it because I am risk-averse when it comes to my hormone levels. Are you a vegan or somehow restricted in your diet?
Reply
#19

Fact or Bro-Science?

Here's one:

If you masturbate you will go blind.

Fact or bro-science?
Reply
#20

Fact or Bro-Science?

Quote: (04-04-2013 01:24 PM)Aliblahba Wrote:  

Here's one:

If you masturbate you will go blind.

Fact or bro-science?

My vision is 20/20, however my palms are getting some hairy.
Reply
#21

Fact or Bro-Science?

walk on an empty stomach every morning and do HIIT once or twice a week depending on your split. You'll see some great results.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)