Are you looking for the super smooth look or just something slightly shorter than a Number 1?
What I suggest:
* I've used Gillette Fusion and Wilkinson Sword Hydro 5, not sure if you can get them in the US
* Use oil and cream - don't skimp on this, and don't use foams or gels, I found I cut myself a whole lot less using good Shaving Cream
* If you want to be smooth, you're gonna have to go against the grain, but don't let that put you off.
What I suggest:
* I've used Gillette Fusion and Wilkinson Sword Hydro 5, not sure if you can get them in the US
* Use oil and cream - don't skimp on this, and don't use foams or gels, I found I cut myself a whole lot less using good Shaving Cream
* If you want to be smooth, you're gonna have to go against the grain, but don't let that put you off.