rooshvforum.network is a fully functional forum: you can search, register, post new threads etc...
Old accounts are inaccessible: register a new one, or recover it when possible. x


Roe v. Wade and why Kavanaugh matters so much
#26

Roe v. Wade and why Kavanaugh matters so much

ms224, you are confusing two different things.

As for abortion, what is likely to happen is some states will add restrictions on abortions. For example, parental notice, or you have to be 18. These limitations have been held to purchase a firearm, which is a fundamental right in the Bill of Rights, so its hard to imagine the current court not upholding these limits on invisible rights.
Reply
#27

Roe v. Wade and why Kavanaugh matters so much

^^^ so privacy and invisible rights are not the same and not viewed the same in the Constitution? The issue was that the court originally conflated the two during the ruling of RvW? What is superceded? Aside from declared rights?

Also, why hasn't this been taken up as an official amendment? Wouldn't a line about the freedom over your (adult ) self be enough to encompass abortion (devil's advocate)? Or is it purely just on States having an interest to the protection of its citizens?

That is a lot I am putting out there for discussion but I'd like to keep the debate and conversation going in this thread.
Reply
#28

Roe v. Wade and why Kavanaugh matters so much

If a right is fundamental, the government has a high burden to justify infringing that right. It need s a compelling interest. If it's not a fundamental right then the government has a very low standard, it needs to show merely a rational basis.

Griswold and Roe basically day that abortion, contraception are fundamental rights even though not enumeratd in the Constitution.

As far as amending the Constitution that is possible but requires approval by 38 states. So very difficult
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)