Every now and again, I like to take a step back and re-evaluate a situation. To get new facts and viewpoints, but also to make sure I don't lose sight of the 'trees for the woods'.
This is an alternative viewpoint that some of you may find interesting:
I certainly did.
I do however disagree vehemently with his assertion that using a VPN makes no difference as the 'metadata' is still being served. I'll go as far as calling him out and say he just doesn't know what he is talking about. Maybe he has studied this subject for longer than the hundreds of hours that I have, but I doubt it. On this point he is talking rubbish. I will give him the benefit of the doubt and concede that it is easy to get confused with all the browser fingerprinting and whatnot - in that case he has a point.
But the fact of the matter is, if you use a VPN on a fresh install with a locked down browser (see Valentines post after my little guide in the VPN thread) - no one will have a clue who you are. Of course, if you are so stupid that you go and order something on Amazon with your credit card, then yes, they will know who you are. But still it will have to be Amazon then feeding back that info and it being collated on the other databases. It is extremely confusing when you get down to it. But the fact remains, a VPN is invaluable for many things if you keep your wits about you.
If you used a VPN, there would be absolutely NO metadata at all that your ISP could see. All that metadata goes through google (and it will) and any purchases you make with your credit card via ebay, amazon, etc. etc. - of course. So this may be the source of his confusion.
If I get busted, I will know that either:
A: My particular VPN is compromised - and the shit will really hit the fan then.
B: It was Amazon that sold me down the river (ho ho ho).
C: It was google ((youtube)) that passed on my information.
D: Some other service depending on what it is I get busted for.
By busted, I mean, for example, someone in a position of authority presenting me with the fact I am a member of RVF and therefore a hate-monger. One example. I don't do anything naughty remember, so I am clean.
The trouble is, depending on how you get busted and what you get 'busted' for, it could be very difficult indeed to work out which one fucked you over.
It may even be that other things are in play and they just go straight to GCHQ or NSA and request your info. But even my evil feminazi neighbour might have difficulty in pulling that one.
Others, like MPs, not so much. These fuckers have power and they will crush you in to the ground at the first opportunity to show you who is boss. And they won't furnish you with the source of your leak.
In a way, I am a canary in the coal mine. I'm just starting to make provisions with 3rd parties for such eventualities. Though the fuss I am making is very very small - these bastards are so used to getting their own way, that any uppity little fucker that dare question their authority gets taught pretty quick who is in charge. Happened to me before, and they have much more ammo now.
Then again, maybe I have overblown this. Maybe this is just pure psyops and the threat of 'we know where you live' is enough to keep most people quiet.
I am always open to opposing viewpoints and to entertain the fact I may be wrong about something. I'm just putting one viewpoint out there for others to consider.
I hope my meanderings are not out of place here in the VPN thread. I believe it is apropos.