Quote: (12-28-2016 08:43 PM)John Michael Kane Wrote:
Quote: (12-28-2016 07:25 PM)Rob Banks Wrote:
OP, I don't think the question of whether a mixed-race child will be discriminated against is the most important issue here. Sure, it is an important issue, as you want your children to grow up being accepted by the larger community. But in my opinion, racial discrimination by others should not be the biggest problem in the world, at least if you are living in the US.
I'm not sure where I will be living long-term, which is why I solicited so many different opinions. Regardless of the race you marry, raising a family in what has become the burning trash heap of American culture is one hell of a challenge, spiritually and legally. Although I love my country dearly, I feel I am in exile here. I think Trump will challenge some of the prevailing political correctness that has ruled over us for far too long, but that isn't changing Family Law that is biased against men, or this ridiculous 58 gender pronoun crap that our universities are pushing. There are plenty of advantages to living in the USA, but raising children here I don't think is one of them, unless you truly move them out to the middle of nowhere.
Quote:Quote:
The reason why I, personally, would prefer not to have children with a non-white woman (I am white/half Jewish) is because I want to have children who look like me and have a similar genetic makeup to me.
On some level, I agree with that argument. Having strong resemblance to your family lineage is a plus. I'm a mix of Portuguese, English, Irish, Scottish, French, German, Flemish, and Italian. I've had many people say I look even Greek or Jewish, because I have darker features and curly hair. I've often been mistaken for Italian. I don't look particularly Irish, even though I have a considerable percentage in me. Here in the United States, most of us are mutts to begin with. I think in continental European cultures, there's a more homogenous look to "blend in". Your average German looks very "German" to me, whereas your average white American just looks, like...a mixture of white ethnic groups.
Quote:Quote:
I remember a conversation I had with my Italian grandmother recently. I asked her if she knew where all her ancestors were from, and she responded with the name of a town near Genoa, Italy. I responded "What about the rest of your ancestors? They can't all be from that town, right?" And she responded that they were, in fact, all from the same town. And then it dawned on me that it was the norm throughout the vast majority of human history for all of one's ancestors to have been from the same town, let alone country. I then asked my grandmother if all of my grandfather's ancestors came from the same town, and she told me that they all came from the same town in Basque Country (northern Spain).
I think family history, and love of roots are an important part of culture. Still, when taken to a logical extreme as in the case of the Ashkenazi Jewish community, many ultra-traditional cultures like Pakistan you start getting inbreeding and genetic problems, with increased health issues and mental neuroticism. Given that I'm a mixture of over a half-dozen different white ethic groups, who is my "home" culture? Sure, if I met a very traditional white 20 year old American girl that wants to marry a 32 year old (me) and have my kids, and be a respectful wife and mother, I'd hop all over that. I believe going to a foreign culture requires extra hurdles to leap in some instances that you don't have with marrying a native. That being said, how many girls in the West are even considering being a loving wife and mother at age 20? The amount of neurotic white women in America is staggering. Over 1 in 4 are on mental health drugs. These are not the foundations I want for a marriage, even if it might sadly mean giving up the "looks" of my ancestors if I marry a woman from a different culture. For the men of this forum who are looking for wives, there is simply a shortage of qualified white, American women, our natural mating cohort. We can't invent more wonderful women. They will either come round on their own, or men will choose other options, or take a sucker's bet.
You mentioned that you're half-Jewish.
Look at Israel, founded by Jews from Soviet countries, German Jews, French Jews, etc. There's no one completely "Jewish" look, but rather a blend. I'm not sure looking like family members of times gone by is the most key factor to a happy marriage. I think the good genes of your future mother, plus a set of spiritual and cultural values that agree surpass that in my own opinion. If I could find that in a white girl who had all those traits, born in America and wanted to get married young before riding the cock carousel, then I'd certainly see that as a plus. There JUST AREN'T MANY of those types of women. The men of this forum giving serious consideration to marriage need to consider foreign options, because their a severe shortage of marriage-quality women in the USA. Full stop.
Quote:Quote:
Considering that what I just described was the norm throughout most of history, I would worry about what kind of effect it would have mixed-race (half-white, half-Asian) children if their mother and father come from opposite sides of the world, from cultures so vastly different from one another. I would be more worried about the child dealing with internal identity issues than external ones. What would it feel like if you looked nothing like your mother or your father? Every time you spent time with your extended family from either side, you would be seen as the outsider. During family get-togethers, everyone at the table would look similar to each other and share a cultural identity, except for you.
A valid point. Thankfully I don't have an ultra racist family. I have an uncle who is Portuguese who married a Mexican. They have a wonderful marriage. That's but one example of two different cultures merging. If I was to marry a white girl in the United States, do I teach them my over half-dozen European identities? I think the case can be made in Europe it matters more to maintain that familial line and "look", as the individual countries are more homogeneous than here in the USA. Europeans have a long history of being more tribal and nationalistic when it comes to race than Americans. Most white Americans are a mix of at least three or four different European backgrounds. We don't have a solidified "white" identity. That's why the KKK isn't ever going to make a strong comeback. Most white Americans don't strongly identify with their European roots. I think it would be nice if we stopped demonizing white folks here in the US as racists all the time, but that's something out of my direct control and ability to change. European identity has been dormant for too long, and I think it will rise again to face the Islamic hordes and I hope so. The chart and path of Europe is very different than that of white Americans. I don't think there is a parallel.
Quote:Quote:
My wife, who I plan on starting a family with, happens to be of similar genetic makeup as me. Like me, she also has Italian and Basque ancestry. However, I did not know this when I met her. In fact, I did not know she had Italian blood until relatively recently. However, I don't think this was merely a coincidence. I think one of the reasons I was drawn to her (and her to me) was because of our similar genetic makeup. I think it is simply in our nature to look for husbands/wives who are genetically similar to us, because that is what we did for the vast majority of human history.
Yes, before modern travel, people mostly mated with folks in their village or nearby towns. There are a more standardized look of a country. In the era of mass transportation, that is not true. In fact, even before airplanes and boats, there have been many wars fought which have changed the genetic makeup of the lands. Look at your Italian history for example. I've met plenty of Italians with silver or blue colored eyes and even with red or blonde hair! You might even think of them as Scandinavian before being sons or daughters of Italy.
Quote:Quote:
As for the whole white-worship thing that goes on in Asian cultures (especially among Asian women), I believe it is a recent cultural phenomenon based on the fact that whites are perceived to have more money and higher status. I once had a Thai girl I went out with tell me that people back in Thailand tell her she is ugly because her skin is too dark (her skin wasn't even all that dark). If I were Asian, I would surely be offended by the way Asian women seem to worship whites, and by the way white culture in general is worshipped. Then again, maybe I am oversimplifying the situation. I am not Asian, so maybe someone who is Asian (or has lived in east Asia) can explain this phenomenon better than I can.
Make no mistake, that there are certainly a sizable number of Asian women (especially from the poorer countries) that see marrying a white man as a step up. They are probably right to think so. I have nothing against them for waiting to get the best deal at the bargaining table, as do I. Keep in mind that my target for wife searching is educated in her own country. I'm not looking for some poverty row girl that just wants a meal ticket. I want a strong, smart woman to raise children with. That means she has a brain and knows how to use it, not just waiting for a white savior. That's where a man must filter strongly!
Right now, white American women are some of the most spoiled brats ever to walk the face of the Earth. I know a few exceptions to that rule who are wonderful wives and mothers. But today's generation of young, white American women are a disaster. Marrying one (other an a truly exceptional angel) would be a recipe for disaster in my opinion. That "Wife Hunting Abroad" thread wouldn't be dozens of pages deep if many other men had come to that same conclusion. The divorce stats don't lie. American men who marry women from abroad have MUCH lower divorce rates. If you go through all the hassle of marrying a woman from abroad, it is because you've done all the extra filtering and homework worth making it worth it. I'd still marry a white American girl in a heartbeat if she had the temperament of many Asian girls, and the desire to be a mother and wife to me. Those are massively tall orders for women that by and large have left that role in droves. You can't convince someone to do something they don't want to. I can't call the shots with regards to what American women want. If I find a unicorn, I'll marry her. But in the mean time, exploring foreign options is in the interest of every American man.
I agree 100% when it comes to American women. My woman is not American. I met her when I was living in South America (she is from the same town as my family). I won't say the specific country, but it is a very white country in South America, populated mostly by Europeans.
I'm would never tell any American guy not to go abroad to look for a wife. I don't think I've ever even met an American woman who I would consider wifing up, and I'm not exaggerating (oddly enough, the only woman I ever met in America who I would have considered potential wife material was a Thai girl who was in town for the summer).
I'm also not saying that you need to find a woman that exactly matches your genetic heritage. My woman doesn't completely match my heritage. I have some Jewish heritage and she doesn't. She has some Native American heritage and I don't. I was just pointing out that I was drawn to her before I knew her heritage, and then it turned out she had mostly the same heritage as me (Italian and Basque), and I don't think this was merely a coincidence. However, if it had turned out that she was half German and half Portuguese (or which I am neither), it wouldn't have made a difference to me.
I'm not here to preach against race-mixing, or anything like that. I think we should let people naturally group together however they see fit. I do, however, believe that people have a natural desire to group together with their own kind. I, personally, would not restrict myself to only dating women of the same ethnic background as me, but at the same time, I probably would not go as far as marrying an East Asian woman. They are simply too different, genetically and culturally. I would feel like I could not have a genuine connection with the woman. Plus, as I have said before, I would want my kids to look at least somewhat like me.
I certainly have sympathy for why men would look abroad for a wife. However, I have to ask myself, is East Asia the only option? What about Eastern Europe, or South America? I guess I just have a personal preference for women who are at least somewhat similar (genetically and culturally) to me, and I think it is natural to have this preference. That being said, I undertand that some men don't have this preference, and that's absolutely fine. It is certainly possible for interracial couple to be happy, as long as you both understand what you're getting into and you're both on the same page about how to handle certain problems that may come up, especially when it comes to raising children.