Posts: 4,481
Threads: 0
Joined: Nov 2012
Otto Weininger - Sex And Character
03-28-2014, 02:41 AM
The dude wrote the book and then killed himself at 23.
I think his suicide was responsible for the book becoming a cult hit in Europe at the time. Even to the point of other young people being inspired to carry out copycat suicides.
I have never gotten round to reading it though. But it sounds interesting.
Posts: 4,481
Threads: 0
Joined: Nov 2012
Otto Weininger - Sex And Character
03-28-2014, 03:37 PM
I read a biography of Wittgenstein.
In there it mentions that one of Wittgenstein's favourite books was the Otto Weininger one (mentioned above).
Later in life - Wittgenstein found out that he was actually Jewish. And despite that - he agreed with the anti-semite sentiments in the Weininger book which argued that Jews were not capable of true creativity - and instead had to steal and vary the ideas of other cultures.
Seems Wittgenstein had some of that self-hating Jew stuff going on. And he even applied these sentiments to his own philosophical work.
Although to be fair - I really don't think Wittgenstein was that original. His early work was mostly based on Schopenhauer and Frege. And his later work was pretty rubbish - and even then lesser known philosophers such as Gilbert Ryle were coming up with similar ideas.
Just my opinion! I know about 50% of philosophers think Wittgenstein was the greatest philosopher of all time. I went to a university where that viewpoint was common.
Posts: 5,184
Threads: 0
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation:
264
Otto Weininger - Sex And Character
03-28-2014, 09:11 PM
cardguy, have you ever tried reading Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations?
same old shit, sixes and sevens Shaft...
Posts: 4,481
Threads: 0
Joined: Nov 2012
Otto Weininger - Sex And Character
03-29-2014, 02:51 AM
Yeah - I have read 'Philosophical Investigations'. I have read all of his work actually (for instance the colour notebooks and a few other smaller books).
For what it is worth - I preferred the Tractatus to his later work. But I think philosophy is a very subjective field. To begin with - everyone has a different conception of what Philosophy is. And it is only once you have decided that - that you can get around to seeing how you feel about a philosopher's work.
Posts: 5,184
Threads: 0
Joined: Aug 2013
Reputation:
264
Otto Weininger - Sex And Character
03-30-2014, 12:27 PM
cardguy, if you are ever interested in re-reading the Investigations, I would be curious to see if you think about it differently now (I presume you read it some years ago when you were still a student).
For what it's worth, I believe that the Investigations is the most important contribution to philosophy since Plato. There are insights achieved there that no one has had before Wittgenstein, and that have not really been understood by anyone since then, because they are so counter-intuitive. There are common errors and prejudices in the way virtually all people think when they are doing philosophy or thinking quite generally that have muddled and continue to muddle all abstract thought including all of contemporary "analytic philosophy", and I think that Wittgenstein made a fundamental breakthrough in understanding these errors and explaining them in the Investigations.
I consider the Investigations the best, most original, and most important book I've ever read and the one that has influenced my thinking more than any other. If anyone wants to read or re-read it and has questions or comments about it, I'd be very happy to respond to them. The one thing I would recommend with it is to go slow. Because Wittgenstein's insights are so counter-intuitive and unusual, he had to choose an indirect method of attack in the book, and while none of the material seems technically difficult, it can be very easy to miss the point. One has to keep coming back to certain things again and again until one has an "aha!" moment and one's whole point of view suddenly changes. But the superficial reader can miss all of the action. As Wittgenstein himself quipped once, in philosophy the winner of the race is the one who finishes last, and that is certainly a good guideline to keep in mind in attempting to understand his text.
same old shit, sixes and sevens Shaft...
Posts: 4,481
Threads: 0
Joined: Nov 2012
Otto Weininger - Sex And Character
03-30-2014, 12:53 PM
Yeah - I will read it at some point. Knowing you are a big fan means alot to me since you are my favourite poster on the board. So - I will definitely reconsider his work at some point.
Philosophy is difficult for me. I used to read it all the time. But now I can only read it when the mood grabs me (which is quite rare).
Anyway - here are some links you might enjoy:
Here is an unpublished Wittgenstein archive which is being prepared for publication.
http://www.cam.ac.uk/research/news/unpub...e-explored
And here is an interesting magazine (from 1997) article on the controversy surrounding the decades long battle to publish Wittgenstein's unpublished works.
http://www.theatlantic.com/past/docs/iss...n/witt.htm
As for my tastes - here is a review I wrote of my favourite philosophy book:
http://www.rooshvforum.network/thread-25063-...#pid501932